The Butter Thief

Name: The Butter Thief
Ingredients: 1.5 oz Rittenhouse Rye; .75 oz BG Reynolds Hot Buttered Rum Mix; .75 oz Whole Milk; .5 oz Demerara Syrup; .25 oz Licor 43; .25 oz Allspice Dram

+ 2 Likes

By Deez Cocktails

Made with a product from a current or former Crafted Pour partner. The creator may have received free product or other incentives from the brand.

Submitted on: February 19, 2026

Communal

Essentials

Winter milk punch meets spiced Old Fashioned

Ingredients

1.5 oz
Rittenhouse Rye

.75 oz
BG Reynolds Hot Buttered Rum Mix

.75 oz
Whole Milk

.5 oz
Demerara Syrup

.25 oz
Licor 43

.25 oz
Allspice Dram

Tools

Boston Shaker

Instructions

Garnish

Ground cinnamon /Cinnamon stick

Build

Shake & Double Strain

Glass

Coupe

Estimated strength

About 15% ABV (estimate)

By Deez Cocktails

Not your average cocktail enthusiast

Other Recipes by Deez Cocktails

Colada's Evil Twin

The Spicy Pineapple

Combine all of the ingredients in a shaker with ice. Shake until chilled, then double strain into a coupe glass. Garnish with fresh grated cinnamon and a scorched cinnamon stick.

Editor's Note

Rye meets the rich, spiced profile of a winter milk punch. The buttered rum mix adds a velvety texture that carries the allspice and vanilla notes through to the finish.

Links

Instagram

Ratings & Comments (1)

Want to add a rating, comment, or photo?Open the app

Crafted Pour

12 April 2026

This looks like the perfect cozy cocktail for a winter evening! The combination of rye with those warm buttered rum spices and Licor 43 sounds incredibly delicious.