Not Your Mama's Rum Cordial

Name: Not Your Mama's Rum Cordial
Ingredients: 2 oz Spiced Rum; 2 oz Whole Milk; 1/2 oz Maraska Nocelino Chocolate; 1 bar spoon Pineapple Brown Sugar Buttered Rum Tincture

By Robin K

Made with a product from a current or former Crafted Pour partner. The creator may have received free product or other incentives from the brand.

Submitted on: February 3, 2023

Seasonal

Spirit Forward

Whenever I go home to Cleveland, I make sure to stop at The West Side Market for some nostalgic provisions. One of my favorite items is a bag of cordials from the little market by the Bratwurst stand. Maybe more than a bag. They have whiskey, coffee, amaretto, and rum flavors. I like them all but the rum ones are definitely a favorite. Now that I’m on the West Coast, it will be harder for me to pop back home to Cleveland for visits. When I do, I’ll be sure to stock up. Cheers!

Ingredients

2 oz
Spiced Rum

2 oz
Whole Milk

1/2 oz
Maraska Nocelino Chocolate

1 bar spoon
Pineapple Brown Sugar Buttered Rum Tincture

Instructions

Garnish

Cocktail Vision Coffee Rim Lick

Build

Blend

Glass

Cocktail Coupe

Estimated strength

About 14% ABV (estimate)

By Robin K

Home Mixologist

🥃Cocktail maker, Storyteller, Home Bartender, Budding Mixologist, Cocktail Photographer🥃

Other Recipes by Robin K

Smoked Saffron Old Fashioned

Figroni

+ 53 More Recipes

Prep glass by dipping rim in Coffee Rim Lick. Place glass in fridge until ready. Add all ingredients to blender with ice. Blend until the consistency of a milkshake. Pour into prepared glass. Drink with or without a straw.

Editor's Note

A dessert‑style milkshake that marries spiced rum with Maraska chocolate liqueur and a pineapple‑buttered rum tincture for tropical richness.

Links

Link Url

Ratings & Comments (1)

Want to add a rating, comment, or photo?Open the app

Crafted Pour

10 August 2026

This sounds like such a wonderful, nostalgic tribute to your time in Cleveland! Do you happen to have the recipe for that Pineapple Brown Sugar Buttered Rum Tincture so others can try making this at home?